What ingredients do I need to make Gary's Poison?

This orange juice-based cocktail has 3 other ingredients. See detailed recipe .

How do I make a Gary's Poison cocktail?

Start with orange juice and mix in 3 other ingredients. See detailed recipe .

How long does it take to mix Gary's Poison?

Gary's Poison has 4 ingredients, and it's pretty quick to mix. See detailed recipe .

Is Gary's Poison a great cocktail?

Gary's Poison is a bartender's pick. This orange juice-based cocktail that's a favorite of 180 other cocktail lovers. See detailed recipe .

Gary's Poison - Cocktail Recipe

Name: Gary's Poison
Prep time: 4 min
Total time: 6 min
Cuisine: American
Ingredients: 5 oz Orange Juice; 3 oz Pineapple Juice; 1/4 oz Triple Sec; 1 1/2 oz captain morgan original spiced rum

Wondering how to make Gary's Poison? Cocktail Builder will help!

Ingredients

5 oz of Orange Juice
3 oz of Pineapple Juice
1/4 oz of Triple Sec
1 1/2 oz of captain morgan original spiced rum (alt: spiced rum)

Instructions

Pour in rum, add triple sec, orange juice and pineapple juice, and serve.

More cocktails with orange juice

Absolutely Lauderdale

Gator Booger

Alabama Slammer

Alabama Slammer Shooter

Gay Bartender

Gecko

Gene Tunney

General Cocktail

Bailey's Madras

Gentle Ben

Gentle Sun Tan

George of the Jungle

Georgia Gin

Blue Bazooki

Georgia Peach

Georgia Peach #2

Bourbon Rose

Georgia Pie

Bronx Cocktail No1

Fuck in the Graveyard

Cocktails for Your Memorial Day BBQ

Memorial Day marks the beginning of good weather, camping, graduations, and barbecues. It’s the season of refreshing, crisp coc... (more)

5 Recipes You Need for World Negroni Week 2026

(more)

From Peas to Pot: 4 Cocktails That Are Going Green

There’s going green and then there’s going green. (And we don’t mean being environmentally friendly.) When it comes to the w... (more)