What ingredients do I need to make Captain Butter Cream?

This cream soda-based cocktail has 2 other ingredients. See detailed recipe .

How do I make a Captain Butter Cream cocktail?

Start with cream soda and mix in 2 other ingredients. See detailed recipe .

How long does it take to mix Captain Butter Cream?

Captain Butter Cream has 3 ingredients, and it's pretty quick to mix. See detailed recipe .

Is Captain Butter Cream a great cocktail?

Captain Butter Cream is a team's favorite. This cream soda-based cocktail that's a favorite of 20 other cocktail lovers. See detailed recipe .

Captain Butter Cream - Cocktail Recipe

Name: Captain Butter Cream
Prep time: 4 min
Total time: 6 min
Cuisine: American
Ingredients: 12 oz Cream Soda; 1 oz dekuyper buttershots liqueur; 2-3 oz captain morgan original spiced rum

Wondering how to make Captain Butter Cream? Cocktail Builder will help!

Ingredients

12 oz of Cream Soda
1 oz of dekuyper buttershots liqueur (alt: butterscotch liqueur)
2-3 oz of captain morgan original spiced rum (alt: spiced rum)

Instructions

Pour Captain Morgan into a pint glass with ice, and add buttershots. Top off with the cream soda of your choice. Shake, do not stir, and serve.

More cocktails with cream soda

Captain's and Cream

Captain's and Creme

Chocolate to Die For

Cinnamon Cream

Comfy Cream Soda

Nichols' Flaming Cocktail

Cream of Jack

Cream Reaper

Cream Seven Simulator

Cream Soda Shaker

Creamin' Beemin'

Creamjager

Creamy Comfort

Creamy Sam

Red Headed Schoolgirl

Crime of Passion

One Ball Left

Orange Cream Dream

Danger Bomb

Painting Pink

6 Cocktail Trends to Look Out for in 2026

Like fashion and food, the landscape of cocktails is largely predicted by popular trends. Thanks to the resurgence of classic cock... (more)

Mother’s Day Cocktail Ideas

You owe your mom a drink. Forget the flowers or the breakfast-in-bed this Mother’s Day. Make your mom a stiff drink she’s sure... (more)

New Year’s Resolutions for the Cocktail Lover

Everyone usually has the same, traditional New Year’s resolutions: losing weight, eating better, or traveling more. Those are de... (more)